OK what would you do? Rebuilt auto or 5-speed???
#1
OK what would you do? Rebuilt auto or 5-speed???
Got the word back that the car is fine save for a new radiator. Which is good news because it means the head is fine. Also Ozark said my compression numbers look good so I'm now looking for a new tranny to install down the road. I see I have several options:
1) Buy a used one from eBay, around $600 shipped + $500-$600 to have a shop install it. This is the cheapest option, but no guarantees on how long it'll last.
2) Getting a rebuilt one from Transmission Planet for $1100 shipped to my door, w/ 2 year unlimited mileage warranty. Then another $500-$600 for a shop to install it.
3) Somehow find all the parts for a 5-speed and pay someone to swap it. I know parts are around $1000 or so, I was thinking of having tech do the swap but not sure if he's up for it and how much he would charge.
Thoughts??? I vote 5-speed but it would take a lot of time and patience to get that stuff together, plus I'd need someone who really knows what they are doing to do the swap.
Car has ~150k on it, other wise seems great, which is why I want to put another tranny in it instead of selling it.
1) Buy a used one from eBay, around $600 shipped + $500-$600 to have a shop install it. This is the cheapest option, but no guarantees on how long it'll last.
2) Getting a rebuilt one from Transmission Planet for $1100 shipped to my door, w/ 2 year unlimited mileage warranty. Then another $500-$600 for a shop to install it.
3) Somehow find all the parts for a 5-speed and pay someone to swap it. I know parts are around $1000 or so, I was thinking of having tech do the swap but not sure if he's up for it and how much he would charge.
Thoughts??? I vote 5-speed but it would take a lot of time and patience to get that stuff together, plus I'd need someone who really knows what they are doing to do the swap.
Car has ~150k on it, other wise seems great, which is why I want to put another tranny in it instead of selling it.
#2
Only 145,000 miles and you need a new trany? My AW71 (745T) has 257,000miles and it is still going strong. Do the newer transmission suck that bad?
Anyways....
I think the 5-speed would be a nice option. Tech said that there are some guys on the other forums (VS, or swedespeed) who sell everything need to do the install.
Anyways....
I think the 5-speed would be a nice option. Tech said that there are some guys on the other forums (VS, or swedespeed) who sell everything need to do the install.
#3
I strongly considered the 5spd swap, because mechanically it did not look too bad (lots of info on volvospeed). However, when I read more about the troubles people had getting all the electrical issues taken care, it no longer seemed worth it. You have to trick the ECU and OBD to stop looking for the auto trans. If your state has really strict inspection and e-check it sounds like a real hassle.
Definitely read up on the other forums. And if you decide to do it, post pictures!
Definitely read up on the other forums. And if you decide to do it, post pictures!
#4
I strongly considered the 5spd swap, because mechanically it did not look too bad (lots of info on volvospeed). However, when I read more about the troubles people had getting all the electrical issues taken care, it no longer seemed worth it. You have to trick the ECU and OBD to stop looking for the auto trans. If your state has really strict inspection and e-check it sounds like a real hassle.
Definitely read up on the other forums. And if you decide to do it, post pictures!
Definitely read up on the other forums. And if you decide to do it, post pictures!
What did you end up doing about your tranny?
In regards to the tranny, most don't suck, but myself and tech have the same issue we don't know what it is. I even wrote the company who rebuilds them for Volvo and they don't know. It drops out of gear when coming to a stop into neutral, then you tap the gas and it "pops" and jerks back into 1st. Weird. But annoying and you know eventually it's going to just let go. Mine went on the same fluid for 143,000 miles so that probably contributed to it. Plus I grew up driving the car and would neutral drop it into drive to spin the wheels. Hey - I was 16 and trying to look cool driving a station wagon....
#5
FYI...you can get a ECU from a Manual car, that way there should be no "electrical" problems, if you swap.
That is strange that you guys have that problem witht your transmissions. I thought Volvo had a Software update for the Transmission? Maybe that is for a different model.
That is strange that you guys have that problem witht your transmissions. I thought Volvo had a Software update for the Transmission? Maybe that is for a different model.
Last edited by TIPSP; 02-13-2009 at 05:48 PM.
#6
#7
Is this car a turbo or a N/A? If it is an N/A it is an easy deal - just get a manual ECU. On a turbo it is tougher since they never had a manual/5 speed combination in the US. I really wish IPD would flash a chip to deal with it but they likely have some copyright issues that prevents them from doing it.
...Lee
...Lee
#9
Got the word back that the car is fine save for a new radiator. Which is good news because it means the head is fine. Also Ozark said my compression numbers look good so I'm now looking for a new tranny to install down the road. I see I have several options:
1) Buy a used one from eBay, around $600 shipped + $500-$600 to have a shop install it. This is the cheapest option, but no guarantees on how long it'll last.
2) Getting a rebuilt one from Transmission Planet for $1100 shipped to my door, w/ 2 year unlimited mileage warranty. Then another $500-$600 for a shop to install it.
3) Somehow find all the parts for a 5-speed and pay someone to swap it. I know parts are around $1000 or so, I was thinking of having tech do the swap but not sure if he's up for it and how much he would charge.
Thoughts??? I vote 5-speed but it would take a lot of time and patience to get that stuff together, plus I'd need someone who really knows what they are doing to do the swap.
Car has ~150k on it, other wise seems great, which is why I want to put another tranny in it instead of selling it.
1) Buy a used one from eBay, around $600 shipped + $500-$600 to have a shop install it. This is the cheapest option, but no guarantees on how long it'll last.
2) Getting a rebuilt one from Transmission Planet for $1100 shipped to my door, w/ 2 year unlimited mileage warranty. Then another $500-$600 for a shop to install it.
3) Somehow find all the parts for a 5-speed and pay someone to swap it. I know parts are around $1000 or so, I was thinking of having tech do the swap but not sure if he's up for it and how much he would charge.
Thoughts??? I vote 5-speed but it would take a lot of time and patience to get that stuff together, plus I'd need someone who really knows what they are doing to do the swap.
Car has ~150k on it, other wise seems great, which is why I want to put another tranny in it instead of selling it.
#11
I wouldn't depend on eBay deals as being the best.......I've found, for example, Volvo re-manufactured wheels from other online wheel stores much cheaper than ones on eBay. There are loads of Volvo parts dealers online that you should research for rebuilt or used Volvo transmissions, or even regular transmission shops that might have rebuilt ones or can rebuild yours. For example, a couple years ago we had our Volvo 850 GLT auto transmission rebuilt at East Coast Transmissions in Alexandria, Va, for $1200 total..........parts and labor installed and got a one year/12,000 mile warranty. They also do the more complex transmission repair work for Don Beyer Volvo Dealer so I felt confident they knew what they were doing on Volvos! Also, trying to switch from auto to manual tranmission could be very complicated but you could check with a Volvo transmission speciality shop.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post