'89 240 DL - random engine cut outs
#1
'89 240 DL - random engine cut outs
Engine cuts out at random or "blips", randomly stalls at the idle, randomly stalls when you put your foot on the brake. There is no pattern and the condition cannot be deliberately reproduced. There are no error codes, but the "check engine" light occasionally comes on for a split second after the cutout, but rarely. The. Cutouts seem to be more likely when it is hot and humid, but happens under all conditions and engine temperatures.
The whole vehicle has been overhauled and virtually all componentssensors, etc are new or check out within specs. It is not any of the usual suspects.
When the engine runs, it runs perfect. Oddly enough, it only cuts out when my wife drives the car. I can drive the car for weeks and nothing happens.
Sny thoughts?
The whole vehicle has been overhauled and virtually all componentssensors, etc are new or check out within specs. It is not any of the usual suspects.
When the engine runs, it runs perfect. Oddly enough, it only cuts out when my wife drives the car. I can drive the car for weeks and nothing happens.
Sny thoughts?
#2
This very much sounds like a power loss condition. I once had a Jeep Cherokee that had the identical symptoms. We discovered that the battery hold down was not properly secured and the positive post would occasionally ground to the body causing a power loss. That's probably not what you have but I would check power and grounds first.
Second, the stalling when hot also points toward a vacuum leak. When the engine is cold and more fuel is demanded, the vacuum leak is not as consequential to the smooth running of the engine since the car is running much richer anyway. As the engine warms up and the fuel ratio becomes leaner, it becomes much more sensitive to a vacuum leak.
Second, the stalling when hot also points toward a vacuum leak. When the engine is cold and more fuel is demanded, the vacuum leak is not as consequential to the smooth running of the engine since the car is running much richer anyway. As the engine warms up and the fuel ratio becomes leaner, it becomes much more sensitive to a vacuum leak.
#3
#6
I checked everything. Everything individually checks out. After several weeks of this, I noticed that there actually is a pattern:
First, if the engine stalls and will not restart, if you piddle around with the lead and connector for the CPS, it will restart. Apparently, the mechanics thought it would be a good idea to bend the CPS lead at a right angle right at the connector to the wiring harness. If you straighten it out, the problem goes away. After a couple of days, when the problem starts up again, I find that the right angle bend has returned to the lead at the connector. Apparently it puts enough pressure on the connector that it gets a faulty connection - That is part of the problem.
The other part is that I corrected the connection is such a way that the electrical connection in the plug would have a good contact. That works just fine until the humidity goes above exactly 60% and the engine goes into it's cut out episodes regardless of engine temperature or air temperature. Essentially, the problem becomes excessive above exactly 60% relative humidity and any air temperature.
And here is the other problem that I have noticed - when the engine stumbles, about 50% of the time the "Check Engine" light comes on for about one second and then goes out. If the engine stalls completely at any speed, the dash lights do not come one but all other electrical items keep working just fine. If I check for error codes, there are no stored error codes.
First, if the engine stalls and will not restart, if you piddle around with the lead and connector for the CPS, it will restart. Apparently, the mechanics thought it would be a good idea to bend the CPS lead at a right angle right at the connector to the wiring harness. If you straighten it out, the problem goes away. After a couple of days, when the problem starts up again, I find that the right angle bend has returned to the lead at the connector. Apparently it puts enough pressure on the connector that it gets a faulty connection - That is part of the problem.
The other part is that I corrected the connection is such a way that the electrical connection in the plug would have a good contact. That works just fine until the humidity goes above exactly 60% and the engine goes into it's cut out episodes regardless of engine temperature or air temperature. Essentially, the problem becomes excessive above exactly 60% relative humidity and any air temperature.
And here is the other problem that I have noticed - when the engine stumbles, about 50% of the time the "Check Engine" light comes on for about one second and then goes out. If the engine stalls completely at any speed, the dash lights do not come one but all other electrical items keep working just fine. If I check for error codes, there are no stored error codes.
#7
#8
Something to think about. Through my 40+ years doing this, there is a recurring theme: humidity and condensation. Water collects inside electrical components and bad things happen.
The symptom is always the same: a tiny drop of water will short out a component for a second or two. The voltage burns off the water and it starts working again, until water droplets collect and short out the circuit again. Usually you get strange sudden jerks as the engine stops running, then starts right back up again.
It's often overlooked that you simply have condensation inside the distributor cap, which will cause this problem as well. Good luck.
The symptom is always the same: a tiny drop of water will short out a component for a second or two. The voltage burns off the water and it starts working again, until water droplets collect and short out the circuit again. Usually you get strange sudden jerks as the engine stops running, then starts right back up again.
It's often overlooked that you simply have condensation inside the distributor cap, which will cause this problem as well. Good luck.
#9
AHA! Possible solution!
Here's the scoop:
I also discovered that there are now two error codes recorded in the diagnostic system despite the check engine light not being on (the light comes on briefly when the cut outs occur) - the engine stalls at idle speed, usually as you come to a stop and push the clutch in (car will restart easily and normally 99% of the time) and occasionally it will blip at speed randomly. This always occurs at high humidity regardless of temperature.
The two error codes are:
2-3-2 - Lambda control - too lean or too rich at idle.
2-1-4 - RPM sensor signal intermittently missing.
The 232 is probably caused by the CPS either failing or the signal being interrupted (no spark signal and unburned fuel trips the O2 sensor into thinking the mixture is too rich). So, if the vehicle doesn't want to start, all you have to do is jiggle the connection and the problem goes away, for a while.
The CPS is only about two years old, and I thought that it should not fail after two years, so I checked the cable for any abrasions and discovered something interesting - it appears that someone had squeezed the cable right near the plug with what I would assume was a pair of pliers (the lead wire was flatted and you could see serrations pressed into the wire just at the connector (idiot mechanic probably used pliers to pull the lead into position).
The mechanic who replaced the CPS two years ago claimed the old CPS failed because it was grounding out where the connection passed through the firewall due to the absence of a grommet. This is absurd because the wire for the CPS goes into a bundle of wires and then through the firewall - and the stock grommet is in tact.
So, would it be safe to assume that there has been some kind of failure involving the CPS lead or connector? It worked fine for two years and then suddenly this problem arose.
I also discovered that there are now two error codes recorded in the diagnostic system despite the check engine light not being on (the light comes on briefly when the cut outs occur) - the engine stalls at idle speed, usually as you come to a stop and push the clutch in (car will restart easily and normally 99% of the time) and occasionally it will blip at speed randomly. This always occurs at high humidity regardless of temperature.
The two error codes are:
2-3-2 - Lambda control - too lean or too rich at idle.
2-1-4 - RPM sensor signal intermittently missing.
The 232 is probably caused by the CPS either failing or the signal being interrupted (no spark signal and unburned fuel trips the O2 sensor into thinking the mixture is too rich). So, if the vehicle doesn't want to start, all you have to do is jiggle the connection and the problem goes away, for a while.
The CPS is only about two years old, and I thought that it should not fail after two years, so I checked the cable for any abrasions and discovered something interesting - it appears that someone had squeezed the cable right near the plug with what I would assume was a pair of pliers (the lead wire was flatted and you could see serrations pressed into the wire just at the connector (idiot mechanic probably used pliers to pull the lead into position).
The mechanic who replaced the CPS two years ago claimed the old CPS failed because it was grounding out where the connection passed through the firewall due to the absence of a grommet. This is absurd because the wire for the CPS goes into a bundle of wires and then through the firewall - and the stock grommet is in tact.
So, would it be safe to assume that there has been some kind of failure involving the CPS lead or connector? It worked fine for two years and then suddenly this problem arose.
#11
Bingo! Problem solved. It was the CPS. A new OEM CPS cost me a whopping $40 and took a total of about five minutes to replace from the top end. It wasn't easy - the design engineers thought long and hard to make it as difficult as possible to replace.
The old CPS (put in by an idiot mechanic who took literally two months to do it, all they way claiming it was a bad Jetronic unit, which, of course it was not) used a used part. To make things worse, it looks like the guy grabbed the cable in several places with a pair of pliers and crushed the cable near the connections at both ends. It was a miracle that it even worked at all.
But I'll tell you why this part is so prone to failure - the heat gets to it. It is mostly plastic and the old one was fairly cooked.
The old CPS (put in by an idiot mechanic who took literally two months to do it, all they way claiming it was a bad Jetronic unit, which, of course it was not) used a used part. To make things worse, it looks like the guy grabbed the cable in several places with a pair of pliers and crushed the cable near the connections at both ends. It was a miracle that it even worked at all.
But I'll tell you why this part is so prone to failure - the heat gets to it. It is mostly plastic and the old one was fairly cooked.
#12
#13
I must agree with above. There is a lot of motion on that engine and the CPS dangles back there between the top electrical connection and where it is bolted to the block. It rubs along and eventually the foil shielding wears away and you lose a signal.
For what they cost, replace them when they fail. Before I figured out what was a problem, I spent many hours years ago trying to diagnose a no start condition on a Volvo 4 cyl. When I learned about the crank position sensor and fuel pump relay, I went into high gear diagnostics. LOL
For what they cost, replace them when they fail. Before I figured out what was a problem, I spent many hours years ago trying to diagnose a no start condition on a Volvo 4 cyl. When I learned about the crank position sensor and fuel pump relay, I went into high gear diagnostics. LOL
#15
I must agree with above. There is a lot of motion on that engine and the CPS dangles back there between the top electrical connection and where it is bolted to the block. It rubs along and eventually the foil shielding wears away and you lose a signal.
For what they cost, replace them when they fail. Before I figured out what was a problem, I spent many hours years ago trying to diagnose a no start condition on a Volvo 4 cyl. When I learned about the crank position sensor and fuel pump relay, I went into high gear diagnostics. LOL
For what they cost, replace them when they fail. Before I figured out what was a problem, I spent many hours years ago trying to diagnose a no start condition on a Volvo 4 cyl. When I learned about the crank position sensor and fuel pump relay, I went into high gear diagnostics. LOL
But what it is, is that the cable for the sensor is a shielded cable like you use in RF applications like cable TV. This means that there is a specific impedance to the cable which is altered if the shielding is crushed or violated. If the impedance is off, it will pick up RF burst from a spark plug which puts a notch in the signal going to the ignition module causing the Jetronic unit to misinterpret the RPM data. this in turn will suddenly cause the Jetronic unit to either make the mixture very rich or very lean, which causes a loss of power for a brief instance, and sometimes a total stall.
Virtually every signal from every sensor and every spark/fuel related component goes through the Jetronic unit, which, of course, means you can check every component in the system by simply pulling the bus connection off the Jetronic unit and (if you know the proper pins to connect to) check the resistance of every component in the system. If you are really nit-picky, you can hook up an oscilliscope to any given circuit and test it across a range of voltages or even send false signals to the Jetronic to see how it behaves. But that's if you have too much time on your hands.
The Jetronic units are fairly simple affairs in terms of how they work and how you can fix or 'rebuild' them - most of the parts down to the tiny memory chip are fairly common parts that you used to be able to pick up at a Radio Shack store, or pirate from other electronic equipment.
The funny thing about these Jetronic EFI units and Ignition Modules is that they are nearly identical to (with the exception of the memory chips and circuitry designed to create and record error codes) the electrical fuel injection modules used in the WWI German ME BF 109 aircraft (purely 1930's technology without the vacuum tubes ), but much more simple in design and function.
#16
The funny thing about these Jetronic EFI units and Ignition Modules is that they are nearly identical to (with the exception of the memory chips and circuitry designed to create and record error codes) the electrical fuel injection modules used in the WWI German ME BF 109 aircraft (purely 1930's technology without the vacuum tubes ), but much more simple in design and function.
the LH2.2 ECU is based on an i8048 processor, while the LH2.4 is a i8051 family CPU. all timing and everything is done with digital loops.
the injection in the Mercedes DB601 engines used on most wartime Bf109's was mechanical direct injection, with a piston fuel pump below each cylinder, mechanically timed. early planes used a Juno engine with carburetors
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post